Title: Ridley Scott’s “Napoleon” Faces Mixed Reactions in France: A Controversy Worth Watching
Renowned director Ridley Scott is unfazed by the negative reviews his latest film, “Napoleon,” has received in France. While The Guardian awarded the film five stars, French GQ took issue with the American accents used by French characters. This sentiment was echoed by Le Figaro, which even went so far as to rename the film “Barbie and Ken Under the Empire.”
Adding fuel to the fire, biographer Patrice Gueniffey claimed that Scott’s portrayal of history was “very anti-French and very pro-British.” However, the director remains defiant, asserting that the audiences in Paris loved the film.
Nevertheless, not all critics gave the movie glowing reviews. Peter Debruge of Variety criticized the film as “bloated” and highlighted the distracting romantic subplot between Napoleon and Josephine. In response to historian Dan Snow’s observations of historical inaccuracies, Scott nonchalantly advised him to “get a life,” questioning the accuracy of historical reports and finding amusement in the backlash from his critics.
One notable voice in defense of the film is actor Joaquin Phoenix, who urges viewers to conduct their own studies to gain a deeper understanding of Napoleon.
Regardless of the controversy surrounding the film’s reception, “Napoleon” will hit theaters on November 22, distributed by Apple and Sony.
Scott’s ability to evoke polarized reactions from critics and audiences alike is a testament to his ambition and willingness to challenge established narratives. As a director known for his distinctive style and attention to detail, Scott’s take on Napoleon Bonaparte’s tumultuous life and impact on history promises to be a cinematic spectacle not to be missed.
As anticipation builds, whether “Napoleon” will find favor among French audiences remains to be seen. Nonetheless, Scott’s unwavering confidence in his work makes this a controversy worth watching.
Note: Word count: 312
